Newsletters
Harvard University’s recent decision to place a strict 20% cap on straight "A" grades per undergraduate course highlights the systemic grade inflation crisis across American higher education.
The university is implementing a structural cap on undergraduate marks starting in the Fall 2027 academic year, following a decisive 458-to-201 faculty vote, according to an AFP report.
Under the new guidelines, professors can award a straight "A" to a maximum of 20% of the students in any given course, with a minor buffer allowing for up to four additional top grades under specific circumstances.
Crucially, the policy places no restrictions on lower tiers, leaving instructors free to distribute "A minus (A-)" grades or below without a quota.
During the 2024–2025 academic year, roughly two-thirds of all undergraduate grades submitted at Harvard were straight As.
The administration expects this new cap to recalibrate grading distributions back to 2010 benchmarks, an era when top marks represented a more modest one-third of the total pool.
Faculty members released a statement welcoming the change. "This matters for our students above all. A Harvard A grade will now tell them, as well as employers and graduate schools, something real about what a student has achieved," the statement said. However, undergraduate students are pushing back heavily, with a campus poll revealing an 85% disapproval rating.
Steering an elite institution through this type of reform has proved difficult in the past. Peer institutions like Princeton and Cornell have previously attempted to curb grade inflation, only to walk back their policies in the face of intense institutional friction.
However, Harvard administration remains firm. The initiative is viewed not just as an internal correction, but as a rigorous cultural shift meant to challenge academic complacency and encourage other top-tier universities to confront the same systemic issue.
Set as preferred source
Set as preferred source
1 min read
1 min read
