Five widely held beliefs about success do not hold up against scientific findings, according to a review by University of Central Florida psychologist Bobby Hoffman, as reported by Vice. Hoffman examined myths that have persisted despite years of research.
The 10,000-hour rule gained popularity because it suggests success is within anyone’s reach through enough work. Put in enough time and effort, the idea goes, and success follows in any field.
A meta-analysis led by psychologist Brooke Macnamara found that deliberate, regular practice explains 26% of performance differences in games and 21% in music. In professional fields, practice affects performance by less than 1%. The results indicate that repetition and effort are not enough on their own, and spending 10,000 hours on a task does not necessarily lead to mastery.
Some parents worry that paying children to read or rewarding good grades will destroy their natural motivation. Research shows a different picture.
Researchers who reviewed 40 years of studies found that rewards do not eliminate motivation as commonly assumed. People who enjoyed their work generally performed better, while those offered incentives often completed more work. Rewards affected motivation negatively only under specific conditions.
Many schools have invested in growth mindset programs, which promise higher grades by teaching students that effort can make them smarter.
Researchers who analyzed 63 studies involving about 98,000 participants found little evidence that these programs meaningfully improve academic achievement. Studies reporting more positive results were more likely to have been conducted by researchers who profit financially from the programs.
The concept of grit once became highly popular. The message was clear: those who want to succeed must learn to keep going when everything becomes difficult and they begin to hate their work.
Researchers who examined 88 samples with more than 66,000 participants found only a limited link between grit and success. Much of the concept could already be explained by conscientiousness, a personality trait psychologists have studied for decades.
A study co-authored by Stanford University psychologist Carol Dweck found that people who believe interests are fixed from birth and only await discovery lose enthusiasm more easily when things become difficult. These people are also less inclined to explore subjects they have not experienced before.
Interests, by contrast, generally take shape as people gain experience and improve in a subject.