Newsletters
Abysmal failure has been given a proper French curatorial polish at the Musée des Arts et Métiers. Catastrophes under this roof are labeled and lit up like eclairs in a display case.
But these pastries explode, collapse, or never quite bake.
The exhibition “Flops?!” is less a museum show than a confessional booth for the world’s worst ideas, a place where ambition went to die wearing a prototype badge.
You enter through a warehouse of regret, a kind of industrial graveyard where inventions sit like abandoned shopping carts with doctoral degrees.
The curators tell us—gently, like a therapist explaining your third divorce—that nine out of 10 innovations fail. That 10th bungle, presumably, is the espresso machine in the lobby keeping everyone conscious enough to keep trying.
The first section, cheerfully titled “Oups!,” is a cavalcade of disasters engineered by committees that hated one another. Dangerous toys, unusable gadgets, and devices so overcomplicated they require a user manual and a minor in theology. These are not just failures; they are failures with resumes.
You begin to suspect that somewhere in history, entire teams high-fived after approving a product that could damage both the consumer and the concept of consumer confidence.
Then comes the absurdist interlude, a catalogue of impossible objects by Jacques Carelman, a man who obviously stared into the void and decided to accessorize it. A travel anvil. A wheeled iron. A transparent parasol ideal for those who enjoy getting wet but would like to see it coming. These objects are intentionally useless, which perversely makes them more honest than many real products currently in circulation.
The exhibition’s central trick is that it doesn’t laugh at failure so much as dissect it with the cool enthusiasm of a coroner who enjoys his work.
In a reconstructed design office, visitors can poke through the carcass of the Aramis transport project, a famously doomed attempt at futuristic transit that collapsed under the weight of its own complexity and bureaucratic entropy. It’s the kind of project that begins with sleek renderings and ends with Zoom calls about why there are so many Zoom calls.
Elsewhere, the flops take on a more sinister tone. A radium beauty cream that glowed with promise and then, inconveniently, with radioactivity. A spray-on contraceptive that required the patience of a saint. These are products that bombed not because the market misunderstood them, but because the laws of physics and human dignity intervened.
And yet, the show insists, like a relentlessly optimistic life coach, that failure is not the end. Some ideas were merely premature, like the early electric car, once dismissed and now reborn as the savior of urban guilt.
Others were sabotaged by marketing so misguided that it might as well have been performance art. The lesson, hammered home with Gallic patience, is that innovation is less a straight line than a drunk zigzag through a minefield.
Failure, of course, is a growth industry, which woefully brings us, as every subject naturally does nowadays, to President Donald Trump.
If the curators are serious about expanding their collection, they might consider a satellite wing dedicated to contemporary flops. Front and center would be the proposed Trump Presidential Skyscraper Library, a library-hotel-museum in Miami, a concept clearly assembled from leftover nouns in a branding workshop. It is the architectural equivalent of the spray-on condom: ambitious, confusing, and likely to leave everyone slightly uncomfortable.
Nearby, one could install a multimedia exhibit on Operation Epic Fury, a name and a war so overcooked it demands its own soundtrack. Whether it’s a military exercise, a video game, or a start-up pitch that got out of hand, the Israeli-U.S. war against Iran and Lebanon has the unmistakable jazz of something calculated to sound impressive rather than function coherently.
In the taxonomy of flops, this is the “too much testosterone, not enough blueprint” category.
The genius of “Flops?!” is that it reveals failure as a systems problem. Engineers blame designers, designers blame marketers, marketers blame users, and users blame the universe.
Somewhere in that blame chain lies the truth: innovation is a contact sport played in the dark. When it works, we call it genius. When it doesn’t, it ends up in a glass case in Paris.
What the exhibition beautifully captures with a wink is the thin line between the ridiculous and the revolutionary. Today’s joke is tomorrow’s breakthrough, provided someone survives the prototype phase. The museum doesn’t mock its subjects; it elevates them, fallen soldiers in the war against bad ideas.
Walking out, you feel oddly reassured. Not because the world is full of failure (that was never in doubt), but because folly, curated properly, starts to look like progress wearing a fake mustache.
The wheeled iron, the doomed transit system, the radioactive face cream: each one is a reminder that—unless you’re spending approximately $1.38 billion a day on a feckless war in the Persian Gulf—trying and failing is still preferable to not trying at all.
Still, if the museum ever opens that annex, the French will certainly leave sufficient acreage for Donald Trump and his misadventures. Trump’s history, after all, is still being written, too often by people who should never have been allowed near a prototype.
Set as preferred source
Set as preferred source
5 min read
